TKI main navigation

Ki te Aotūroa - Improving Inservice Teacher Educator Learning and Practice. Ministry of Education.

INSTEP navigation


Moment 3

The third moment for analysis concerns Catherine’s tendency to argue for something rather than checking on the response of the person she’s working with.

Clip 9: Moment 3a.

Clip 9: Moment 3a - 1:31

Play large  |  Play medium

Read transcript

Pause here and use the transcript to discuss:

  • What are the consequences for Jack of Catherine not stopping and checking on how he’s feeling? What are the consequences for herself?
  • Why then do you think Catherine doesn’t stop and check?

Here’s what Catherine, Allan, and Michael thought.

Clip 10: Moment 3b.

Clip 10: Moment 3b - 3:08

Play large  |  Play medium

Read transcript

Catherine and Allan then reran this part of the conversation.

Clip 11: Moment 3c.

Clip 11: Moment 3c - 2:34

Play large  |  Play medium

Read transcript

Pause here and use the transcript to discuss:

  • Why is Jack (as reported by Allan) feeling the most engaged so far?
  • What is it about Catherine’s practice that has achieved this?

Here’s what the participants thought.

Clip 12: Moment 3d.

Clip 12: Moment 3d - 2:08

Play large  |  Play medium

Read transcript

Pause here and discuss:

  • How do you think Catherine might cue herself to stop arguing for something and start checking in earlier?

Perpectives

Viviane Robinson.

Viviane Robinson

Viviane Robinson gives her perspective on a transcript of this moment.

John Loughran.

John Loughran

John Loughran presents an alternative view to that of Viviane Robinson on this moment.

Clip 13: Analysing interpersonal interactions.

Clip 13: Analysing interpersonal interactions - 3:18

Play large  |  Play medium

Read transcript

Return to top



Site map